Jump to content

Wikipedia:Bug reports and feature requests

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
(Redirected from Wikipedia:Software idea)
"Wikipedia:Feature request" redirects here. For the historical archives, see Wikipedia:Feature request (archive) and Wikipedia:Squashed bugs.
"Wikipedia:Feature" redirects here. For Wikipedia's featured content, see Portal:Featured content.

Bug reports and feature requests (collectively called tasks) relating to the MediaWiki software that powers Wikipedia, should be filed on Wikimedia's Phabricator. Phabricator is a software suite that includes tools for bug reporting and project management. The bug report management tool of Phabricator is called Maniphest.

Bug reports and feature requests that are not directly related to the MediaWiki software should be discussed at Wikipedia:Village pump (technical). When in doubt, discuss issues at the Village pump before filing a task on Wikimedia's Phabricator.

Reporting a bug or filing a feature request

[edit]
See also: mw:How to report a bug

You've got a bug or feature request, and you're itching to report it. The first thing you should do is search for an existing report by using the search field in the upper corner. Someone may have already reported the bug or requested the feature. Searching first helps to prevent duplicates. To be effective, try multiple synonyms and rephrasings of what the bug or feature might have been called. Per mw:Phabricator/Help § Formatting and markup you can link to other tickets in the description of the one you're creating simply by typing its ticket ID (such as "T123456"), so you may want to note down the IDs of relevant non-duplicative reports you find.

Create account

[edit]

The next step is to create an account in Phabricator. Thanks to Wikimedia's Single User Login (SUL), you can use your account on mediawiki.org for login and don't have to remember another separate password. Please follow the instructions how to create an account on MediaWiki.org. In contrast to the previous bug tracking system (Bugzilla), your email address will not be displayed in Phabricator.

Details

[edit]

Create your bug report or create your feature request! To understand what the fields mean and how to write a useful task, it is recommended to read "How to report a bug" on MediaWiki. A few details are highlighted below.

Selecting projects

[edit]

In order to relate a task with a project (tag) that uses Phabricator, you just need to start typing its name in the Tags field and select the project from the list of matching projects (the list will only show five matching projects). You can search for projects and read short project descriptions by clicking the magnifier icon in the Tags field. You can add one or more projects to the Tags field. If you are unsure, you can also leave it empty — triagers will take care of tasks that have no project set. There is a (long) list of projects available. Press Edit Query to search for projects. (This list is also available at Phabricator/Projects.)

Problem area - Project

  • Automatic filter/Edit filter - AbuseFilter
  • CAPTCHA - ConfirmEdit
  • Citation autofill - Citoid
  • Graphs - either local (HTTP based), EasyTimeline or Graph
  • Interwiki - Wikidata
  • Log-ins/log-outs - CentralAuth
  • Musical notes - Score
  • Modules - Scribunto or local
  • Reply on talk pages - Discussion tools
  • Search - CirrusSearch
  • Thumbnails - Thumbor
  • Video - TimedMediaHandler

Setting task priority

[edit]

You should not set task priority. Priority should normally only be set by maintainers, not by the reporter filing the bug report or by outside observers. See Phabricator project management for details.

Updates on your task

[edit]
See also: "Receiving updates and notifications" on MediaWiki wiki

By default you will be emailed with updates on the status of your task. Sometimes developers may reject or misunderstand a bug report or feature request and close a report that you think is still valid. If you believe there's still an issue, you can add a comment and try to make a better explanation, or you can take it to the mailing list. If you do not want to get updates on your bug, you can state this in your email preferences.

Finding tasks you have joined the CC/Subscribers list for

[edit]

Go to the list of open tasks that you have subscribed to. You can also edit the search query (e.g. to also include closed tasks) to alter the results.

Tokens

[edit]

Tokens in Phabricator can be used to show which bugs you care about. You can add a token to a report by clicking "Award Token" in the sidebar at the top of a report.

Note that developers are not obligated to implement a request just because it has a large number of tokens.

Etiquette

[edit]
See also: "Phabricator etiquette" on MediaWiki wiki

Phabricator is a place to notify developers of bugs and contribute information that would be useful in the fixing of the bugs. It is not a place for advocacy viz (e.g. "I REALLY WANT THIS BUG FIXED!") With that in mind, please keep the following rules in mind when using Phabricator:

  • Contribute useful comments; useless comments (i.e. advocacy) decrease the signal-to-noise ratio
  • The developers are under no obligation to fix your bug or add a feature you want.
  • No personal abuse: do not make threats like "I will not edit Wikipedia until this bug is fixed"
  • Don't mess around with fields unless you are the bug's assignee or you know what you are doing; instead, comment on the suggested change
  • Don't whine about "declined" decisions
  • Applicability varies, but when in doubt, follow the rules

If you see someone not following these rules, politely mention it to them via their talk page or private email: do not bugspam some more by chastising the user for their conduct publicly.

Linking to bugs from Wikipedia

[edit]
See "Template:Tracked" on MediaWiki for more information about that template.
Tracked in Phabricator
Task T1000

{{tracked|T1000}} creates the first right-floating box -->>

Tracked in Phabricator
Task T1234
Resolved

If you would like to note the fact that the task has been resolved, you can note its status via {{tracked|T1234|resolved}}. See the second right-floating box -->

If you enable the "Enable tracking bugs on Phabricator using the {{tracked}} template" gadget in your preferences, you will always see up to date statuses for Phabricator references that use the {{tracked}} template (even if the template call omits the status or has not been manually updated).

You can link to bugs using the phab: interwiki prefix. For example, type [[phab:T1000]] for phab:T1000. The phab: prefix can be used for linking to any static page in Wikimedia's Phabricator. For example, type [[phab:project/query/all/]] for phab:project/query/all/.

Note that [[bug:T1000]] links to the Buginese Wikipedia, not to Phabricator or its predecessor Bugzilla.

[edit]
See also: mw:Phabricator/Help § Writing comments and descriptions

Links on Phabricator can either use full URL syntax like on Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page displays the full URL) or a wikilink-like syntax with two brackets and a full URL for a link text version ([[https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Main_Page|the main page of the wiki]] displays as "the main page of the wiki"). Markdown link syntax is also supported. Other linking methods besides those are not supported.

Software deployment schedule

[edit]
Shortcuts
See also: wikitech:Deployments

New software on Wikimedia is deployed regularly, usually weekly. Group 0 wikis have their main software changes deployed on Tuesdays (test websites except Test2 Wikipedia, and mediawiki.org), group 1 on Wednesdays (Catalan, Hebrew, and Italian Wikipedias, Test2 Wikipedia, and all non-Wikipedia sites), and group 2 (the rest) on Thursdays. English Wikipedia is in group 2, meaning it receives the main weekly deployment on Thursdays. There are other changes that happen on a different schedule. The current MediaWiki version is 1.43.0-wmf.28 (2693c4c).

If you are experiencing a technical problem with editing or reading on Thursday or Friday which was not present earlier, the cause of that technical problem is likely the recent deployment of software. You can report problems using the guidance on this page or on WP:VPT. If you decide to report the problem on VPT, consider looking for similar issues (usually separate sections toward the bottom of the table of contents/page); you may not be the first person to encounter the issue, and it is good to keep issue discussion in one place. Sometimes the "problem" is the result of a deliberate action to change how the software behaves, so while you can provide a report, there is no guarantee it will be fixed the way you expect, if it needs fixing at all.

When filing a bug in Phabricator for regressions that appear to be related to the new MediaWiki version, please also mention it on that week's "train blocker" deployment bug.

Glossaries

[edit]

See also

[edit]
[edit]
MediaWiki has documentation related to: How to report a bug
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Wikipedia:Bug_reports_and_feature_requests&oldid=1248446782"